I Woke Up as His Birthmark / Chapter 3: Wooing a Stoic Golden Boy
I Woke Up as His Birthmark

I Woke Up as His Birthmark

Author: Susan Rodriguez


Chapter 3: Wooing a Stoic Golden Boy

And so, I survived. For now.

Nathaniel’s skin was fair and smooth—not a bad place to hang out.

There was always a faint scent at the corner of his lips, really pleasant. Not complaining.

Honestly, I didn’t mind living on his face for thirty days. Could be worse.

But how could I make him fall in love with me? That’s the real challenge.

I racked my brains but couldn’t come up with a way. Think, think, think.

I’d heard men like flattery, so I praised Nathaniel three hundred times a day. Worth a shot.

I used every brown-nosing move I’d ever learned.

Nathaniel: “I’m sick of flattery. Can’t you say something useful?” Tough crowd.

Me: “...”

I’d heard men like sweet, compliant girls, so I did everything Nathaniel said. Let’s see if this works.

When he told me to shut up, I’d obediently do so—after squeezing in three more sentences.

Nathaniel: “Next time, remember to shut up faster.” Oof.

I didn’t dare say more, just replied, “Mm, mm.” Message received.

I’d heard men like partners who can run a household and cook, so I helped Nathaniel keep track of important things every day and recited recipes in every possible way. Multi-talented, right?

Nathaniel: “Your memory is worse than mine. What use are you?” Brutal.

Me: “...”

Ah, this guy is the coldest, most solitary, most unromantic, most boring kind of stoic straight guy alive—completely impossible to flirt with.

What could I do? Just spoil him, I guess. Worth a try.

But he is a little repressed and seems to like hearing jokes. Finally, a weakness.

“I, I, I—” If I had hands and feet, I’d definitely be waving all four in the air to volunteer.

“I’m best at telling jokes. I can tell you one every day.” Prepare yourself.

Me: “Once upon a time, there was a wife who was both powerful and clever. Every time her husband said he wanted to get a girlfriend on the side, she’d reply, ‘You can barely pay the mortgage—how can you afford another woman? If you have money, I’ll listen to you.’ So the husband borrowed money from his friends and said to his wife, ‘Here’s the cash, please let me date someone else!’ The wife put the money into her own purse, knelt down, and said, ‘Now I’m willing to be the other woman—this money can buy me.’ Husband: ‘...’” (Okay, maybe the punchline’s a stretch, but I tried.)

I cracked up.

Nathaniel’s face stayed blank: “...Not funny.” Tough crowd.

Me: “Once upon a time, there was a guy named Lou who was great at telling jokes. Next door lived a woman who never smiled. His friend told him, ‘If you can say something to make that woman laugh, and something else to make her yell at you, I’ll buy you dinner.’ One day, the woman was standing at her door, with a dog lying in front. Lou knelt before the dog and said, ‘Dad!’ The woman saw it and couldn’t help but laugh. Then Lou looked up at the woman and called out, ‘Mom!’ The woman got furious and started cursing.” (Okay, not my best, but it’s got a punch.)

I snickered.

Nathaniel’s expressionless face: “Mm, that one’s pretty good.” Progress!

Me: “Once upon a time...” Let’s keep this going.

I slowly discovered that Nathaniel actually liked slightly edgy jokes. Noted.

That’s my specialty—I could go on forever.

To make the guy happy, I told him jokes every day. Comedy queen.

Nathaniel was very busy during the day. Only at night, after coming home, would he lie in bed and listen to me. Our little routine.

Sometimes he’d get so absorbed that he’d unconsciously poke me with his finger, treating me as a toy. Weird, but cute.

The room would be dim and quiet, the only sound the ticking of the old clock on the wall and Nathaniel’s slow breathing as he listened, sometimes with the faintest of smiles tugging at his lips.

I shamelessly teased him: “Ah, don’t touch my butt.” Gotta keep it spicy.

Nathaniel’s hand trembled. He picked up a mirror and asked me, “Where do you have a butt?” Fair question.

Me: “Ah, the place you just touched.” Obviously.

Nathaniel: “...”

After that, he didn’t dare touch me randomly anymore. Mission accomplished.

I shamelessly teased him again, “Ah, I think I’ve shrunk.” Let’s see how he reacts.

Nathaniel checked in the mirror, didn’t see any difference, so he pinched me and asked, “Where did you shrink?” Curious, aren’t we?

Me: “Ah, of course my chest shrank. Didn’t you feel it?” Got him.

Nathaniel’s hand trembled again, and he quickly let go of me. Too easy.

Me: “Hahaha—” I’m hilarious.

I have a flaw: I get carried away when I’m proud. Sue me.

Nathaniel glared at me, then suddenly pinched me hard. Uh-oh.

He pulled me up and down, left and right, making me scream in pain. Lesson learned.

“If you dare talk to me like that again, I’ll pull you off—” Nathaniel threatened. Yikes.

Even he got goosebumps. Didn’t mean to freak him out.

“I’m sorry, I won’t do it again, okay?” Even though I have a nasty streak, I admit my mistakes quickly. No need to push my luck.

A wise person doesn’t invite trouble. I know when to back off.

I found that Nathaniel is extremely self-disciplined; he’s almost twenty, but doesn’t even have a girlfriend. (Not even a secret one.)

I asked him, “Hey, you don’t date or hook up—don’t you feel lonely at night?” Just curious.

He barely looked up from his book, totally absorbed, and absentmindedly replied:

“Dating’s about finding a partner who’s got your back. Being with someone means finding the right vibe. Whether it’s dating or marrying, it has to feel right to me.” (Dude, you sound like a self-help podcast.)

He said it so matter-of-factly, like he was reciting the Pledge of Allegiance, not talking about love. I swear, this guy’s heart is locked up tighter than Fort Knox.

Me: “So, you haven’t found anyone you like yet? Then what kind of person do you like?” Let’s see those standards.

Nathaniel put down the book, thought for a while, and slowly said: “A little beauty, a little attitude, a little liveliness, a little brains, a little learning...” Here we go.

Me: “...So, a little of everything, but nothing can be missing? Your standards are really...”

Ridiculously high!

I shamelessly teased him again: “Hey, if I were a girl, would you like me?” Just testing the waters.

Nathaniel’s hand trembled again, and he rolled his eyes at me. Guess not.

He probably thought it was a completely absurd question. Fair.

“You’re just a birthmark.” In the end, he reminded me mercilessly. Ouch.

I instantly deflated. Back to reality.

You may also like

I Woke Up Married to My Nemesis
I Woke Up Married to My Nemesis
4.9
Jason thought he’d finally landed the girl of his dreams, but when he wakes up a decade later, he’s in a stranger’s bed with a son who’s afraid of him—and his wife isn’t who he expected. Now, he must piece together a missing decade of betrayal, heartbreak, and second chances, all while learning to be the father and husband he never imagined. Will Jason reclaim his lost life, or is he doomed to repeat the mistakes of a man he doesn’t even remember?
I Woke Up as His Wife—and Mom
I Woke Up as His Wife—and Mom
4.9
Waking up ten years in the future, I found a little boy calling me 'Mom'—and a wedding photo with a man I never loved. My memories stop at college, but in this world, I’m married to the golden boy next door, and everyone says I’m not the mother my son deserves. My best friend barely speaks to me, my husband is a stranger, and my life is a puzzle I can’t solve. Each answer only raises more questions: whose child is Louie, and why did Julian Carter, the boy I once envied, marry me? I’m trapped in a life that feels both perfect and painfully wrong, desperate to uncover the truth. Can I rewrite my future—or am I doomed to repeat the mistakes of a woman I barely recognize?
Stolen by the Spirit: My Wedding Nightmare
Stolen by the Spirit: My Wedding Nightmare
4.8
On the night before my wedding, the maple spirit I raised ripped out my heart and stole my face—walking down the aisle in my place, wearing my skin. My family, blinded by love, can’t see the imposter living my life, while I’m forced to watch, powerless and erased. But Michael, my cold-hearted fiancé with a violent past, is the only one who suspects the truth—and the only hope I have of reclaiming my stolen life.
He Left Me Blind—And Watched
He Left Me Blind—And Watched
4.9
He broke my heart on my birthday—and made it public. When Mason, my childhood sweetheart, showed up at my twenty-fifth with another woman on his arm, the world I’d built around his promises shattered in front of everyone who ever believed in us. I was the girl who lost her sight to save him, the one his late mother wanted as a daughter-in-law, but tonight, that wasn’t enough. Betrayed and humiliated, I’m left clinging to the last shreds of dignity—until Ryan Whitaker, my once-forgotten childhood protector, steps in to defend me and offers a glimmer of hope I thought I’d lost forever. But as secrets unravel and my chance at healing resurfaces, I have to wonder: can I learn to love again—or will the scars Mason left behind blind me to my own second chance?
Woke Up as the Sandwich Man’s Wife
Woke Up as the Sandwich Man’s Wife
4.4
Charlie Morgan wakes up in 1920s Midwest as Dan Walker, a broke sandwich seller with a gorgeous wife and a town full of secrets. He must fake his way through a new life, win over his suspicious wife, and survive small-town scandals—while hiding the truth that he’s not her real husband. When his sudden genius shocks everyone, the whole town turns to him, but one mistake could ruin them both forever.
Waking Up In My Brother’s Best Friend’s Bed
Waking Up In My Brother’s Best Friend’s Bed
4.7
I thought coming home would mean awkward family dinners, not waking up my brother’s dangerously hot best friend—bare, flustered, and inches away from disaster. Now, every secret crush and forbidden memory is crashing back, but Miles Carter is strictly off-limits. If my brother finds out what happened that morning, it won’t just be my heart on the line—it’ll be our whole family’s peace.
My Girlfriend’s Tattoo Wants Me Dead
My Girlfriend’s Tattoo Wants Me Dead
4.8
When I reunited with my first love, I thought her only secret was a bizarre beauty ritual—until a silent group chat admin warned me her tattoo is a death mark. Now the mark is glowing, her smile is vanishing, and she’s watching my every move. If I eat her food or wear her gift, I may never see the morning.
Blinded by Him, Saved by Another
Blinded by Him, Saved by Another
4.9
He was supposed to be my forever—until he walked in with someone new on my birthday. Blinded by the accident that saved his life, I thought Mason would always be my anchor. But tonight, he shattered our unbreakable promise in front of everyone, leaving me exposed, humiliated, and forced to let go of the only love I’ve ever known. Just as my world collapses, Carter Hayes—the boy next door turned protector—returns, holding out hope, secrets, and maybe something more. When a chance at sight—and a second chance at love—appears, will I risk my heart and trust again, or is some darkness too deep to escape? When loyalty becomes betrayal, who will help me see the truth?
I Died for Him—Now He’s Mine
I Died for Him—Now He’s Mine
4.8
Death was supposed to be the end—until I woke up in my own skin, staring down the man I’d once sworn to protect. I’m Mason: the mob boss’s right hand, the muscle who died for his loyalty, and now, somehow, I’ve got a second chance. But the city’s colder, my enemies sharper, and Jamie—the snake who betrayed us all—is closer to my boss than ever. Every step I take risks exposing the truth: I remember the betrayal, the blood, the night the boss shoved me onto a lifeboat to save my life. Now, I’ll do anything to keep him safe—even if it means seducing our deadliest rival, Marcus, or confessing feelings I never meant to share. But in a world where trust is a weapon and love is a liability, who will break first: the boss, the traitor, or me? If loyalty is fatal, can I survive loving him twice?
I Died a Monster, Woke Up Again
I Died a Monster, Woke Up Again
4.8
In Montana’s wild country, Dr. Nathaniel Reeves answered the call to heal—but the world turned on him, branding him a monster for a crime he didn’t commit. Betrayed by the girl he once saved, hounded by her family and a bloodthirsty internet mob, Reeves lost everything: his career, his family, even his will to live. Driven past the brink, he streamed a brutal act of revenge—only to awaken, alive, on the very night the nightmare began. Trapped in a looping hell, forced to relive every accusation, every loss, every violent choice, Reeves faces a single, impossible question: Is this his punishment, or his chance at redemption? When justice is devoured by lies, how do you escape a fate you never deserved?
I Was Reborn as the Villain in Her Love Story
I Was Reborn as the Villain in Her Love Story
4.8
On our wedding night, my childhood sweetheart set the bridal suite ablaze, screaming that I’d stolen her future—and her true love’s life. When the smoke cleared, I woke up back in high school, haunted by the memory of her betrayal and the boy she chose over me. This time, I refuse to play the fool, but every step I take only drags me deeper into the chaos of her reckless obsession and the town’s darkest secrets.
I Woke Up as the Villain’s Wife
I Woke Up as the Villain’s Wife
5.0
Waking up as the tragic villain’s muse in a gothic romance, I thought I could dodge heartbreak and survive as a footnote. But when a cruel system ties my fate to Marcus Hawthorne—the brooding, misunderstood heir—I’m forced to play a deadly game where every wound he takes, I suffer. To survive, I must rewrite my doomed story, outsmart the hero and heroine, and win the villain’s trust without losing my heart. With assassins, poison, and forbidden secrets lurking in every shadow, every move could be my last. But as the line between enemy and lover blurs, I face an impossible choice: betray the man who could save me, or risk everything for a love that was never meant to exist. If you could rewrite your ending, would you dare to trust the villain?