I Was the Villain—Then He Chose Me / Chapter 1: Living in Someone Else’s Story
I Was the Villain—Then He Chose Me

I Was the Villain—Then He Chose Me

Author: Rachael Morris


Chapter 1: Living in Someone Else’s Story

Next →

Seven years ago, I woke up in someone else’s life—a supporting character in a story that wasn’t mine. Now, I think I might have fallen for the hero.

Seven years. Sometimes it feels like it happened just yesterday; other times, it’s like a whole lifetime ago. I still remember the first time I caught myself watching Julian Carter, feeling that fluttery, hopeless thing in my chest—like I was standing on the edge of a roof, looking down, heart pounding. It’s funny how you can fall for someone even when you know the script isn’t written for you. Still, here I am, tangled up in someone else’s story, hoping for a plot twist that never comes.

I’ve stood by him for seven years, giving him everything I had, but it all crumbled every time I saw the way he looked at her, the leading lady.

It’s a look you can’t fake, can’t force. The kind of gaze that makes the whole room fade away, like a spotlight shining down. I swear, you can spot it a mile away. Didn’t matter how many times I told myself to get over it. Every time he smiled at Lena Morales, it was like getting hit with a blast of cold air, right in the chest. But I kept smiling, kept playing my part, because that’s what supporting characters do, right?

Still, I keep moving forward, grinding down the heartbreak to dust, chin up, acting like I’m the most carefree girl in Maple Heights.

People around town say I’m unbothered, always laughing, first to crack a joke or hop on a hayride. They don’t have a clue. You get good at hiding heartbreak. Like your favorite old jacket—you wear it, sure, but you never really take it off. Even so, I refused to let anyone see me stumble. I made sure of it. In Maple Heights, reputation is everything, and I wasn’t about to let mine get tangled up in a sad story.

I was only eight when I landed here, with no memory of before. It was the worst of times—civil unrest everywhere, drifting among strangers, barely scraping by on stale bread and wild greens.

Eight years old, alone, and the world was coming apart at the seams. I remember the taste of stale rye, the bitterness of wild dandelion greens I picked by the railroad tracks. Nights spent curled up in barns or under bridges, listening to the distant crack of gunfire. Faces blurred by hunger and fear. I was just a kid. Even now, the smell of wet earth after rain brings it all back—how small I felt, how desperate.

Once, I even stumbled into a bandit raid. That day was all screams and terror, sunset stained red like blood, leaving me cold and shaking.

I’ll never forget that night. The sky was a bruised purple, the sun bleeding out over the hills. The air smelled of smoke and panic. I ran until my lungs burned, tripping over tree roots, heart hammering in my ears. For a moment, I thought it was over—that I’d never see another sunrise. I can still hear the shouts, the clatter of boots, and the way the world seemed to stop as I crouched behind a broken fence, praying to a God I barely remembered.

Finally, I saw the cavalry—badges gleaming, dust rising as they thundered in.

It was like something out of an old Western: horses kicking up a storm, sunlight glinting off silver badges, the sound of hooves shaking the ground. For a split second, I thought I was dreaming. I’d never been so grateful for the sight of lawmen in my life. They rode in like a promise—like hope itself.

He rode in from afar, swinging down off his horse to reach for me. His eyes were like melting mountain snow—cold, but starting to warm.

He looked at me—not through me, not past me, but right at me. I remember the way his coat flared as he swung down, the dust on his boots, the way he knelt in the dirt and offered his hand. There was something in his eyes—sharp, clear, but warm too. Like he could see the whole world and still choose kindness.

In that moment, I almost believed—

For just a heartbeat, I let myself imagine he was my hero, that maybe, just maybe, someone had come for me after all. It was the first time in this world I felt seen, not just another lost child in the chaos. I wanted to believe in miracles again.

He was coming just for me.

The night I spent at the army camp, I finally had my first full meal since I arrived: a real dinner, plenty of water, and the first good night's sleep in forever. When I woke up, memories of this body's past started to come back.

I ate until my stomach ached—real stew, thick bread, cold well water. I slept in a cot with a scratchy blanket, but it felt like heaven. When I woke, the dawn was soft and golden, and I remembered things I hadn’t known before: the sound of my mother’s voice, the weight of my father’s hand on my shoulder, the shape of my old house in the morning light. It was like finding old letters in a forgotten drawer—pieces of a life I’d never lived, but suddenly missed all the same.

My name? Autumn Sinclair. Dad was a self-made man. Followed General Carter for years, worked his way up from nothing. Mom came from the old-money Bellamy family in Savannah, but she died last year.

Autumn Sinclair. The name fit me like a favorite sweater, a little worn but still warm. My dad—Elias Sinclair—was a legend in his own right, a man who built his name from nothing, loyal to General Carter through thick and thin. Mom, with her Bellamy grace and Savannah drawl, died too soon, leaving a hole I never quite filled. I could still hear her singing old folk songs in the kitchen, the echo of her laughter in the halls.

Because of the rebellion, Dad had to go back to the front, so he sent someone to take me down to my uncle’s place in Savannah.

He pressed a letter into my hand, told me to be brave, to mind my manners, and to trust Uncle Henry. I promised I would. The carriage ride south was bumpy and long, the world outside nothing but pine trees and the occasional fox darting across the road. I tried not to cry. I tried to be brave, just like he asked.

But things went sideways.

Disaster after disaster—roadblocks, rumors of raids, strangers who weren’t what they seemed. The world spun out of control, and I found myself alone, again, running with the refugees, clutching my few possessions like they were gold. Every day was a gamble, every night a test of faith.

After a string of disasters, I ended up fleeing with the rest of the refugees.

I learned to keep my head down, to blend in, to move fast when trouble came. I picked up the accent, the slang, the tricks for finding food. Sometimes, I wondered if I’d ever see a safe place again. Sometimes, I just hoped to make it through another day.

Julian Carter.

That name hits me every time. The first time I heard it, it sounded like the answer to a question I hadn’t asked yet. Even now, just thinking it makes my heart skip a beat—Julian Carter.

I'd seen him before, more than once.

He was the kind of boy everyone noticed—tall, dark-haired, eyes like storm clouds about to break. Even now, I can picture him. Even as a kid, he had a presence. The sort of person you remember long after the crowd has faded. He’d show up at parades, at church picnics, at the Fourth of July fair, always surrounded by laughter and light.

Back then, he was all fire and charisma, one of the capital's golden boys—free and wild.

He’d race horses down Main Street, charm the old ladies at the general store, and make the younger girls blush. There was a recklessness to him, a wild edge that made you want to follow just to see where he’d lead. He was the kind of boy who believed he could outrun the world—and for a while, maybe he could.

But when I saw him yesterday? Cold as the moon.

The years had changed him. He moved with a soldier’s caution, eyes scanning every shadow. The easy laughter was gone, replaced by something harder, sharper. He wore responsibility like armor, and it made him look older than his years.

Something had changed.

I could feel it in the way he spoke, the careful way he measured every word. The world had taken something from him, and I didn’t know if he’d ever get it back. I wanted to reach out, to ask, but the words stuck in my throat.

Later, I learned that at the Battle of Willow Creek, nearly half the Carter family was wiped out. My father and Julian's group were ambushed. He barely escaped, regrouped with the surviving Carters, then teamed up with General Brooks to turn the tide, catch the traitor, and return to the capital.

The whole town buzzed with the story—how Julian rode through hell and back, how he pulled together what was left of his family, how he never stopped fighting. They called him a hero. I saw the cost in his eyes.

I just remember him bowing to me, solemn, his voice steady as a promise.

He stood tall, back straight, the kind of posture you learn from years of standing at attention. His words were careful, but there was a warmth beneath them—a promise made not just out of duty, but out of something deeper. I held onto that moment, tucked it away for the nights when the world felt too big and I felt too small.

“Your dad’s last wish was to make sure you were safe. From now on, I’ll protect you.”

He didn’t say it like a command, but like a vow. The kind you don’t break. I wanted to believe him, more than I’d wanted anything in a long time.

When we got back to Maple Heights, after Julian stood up to the young mayor and city council about the traitor, all he got was a new title for himself—County Commissioner. And for me? A ceremonial “county princess” title. Supposedly to honor the general’s orphan, but really just for show.

They made a big deal out of it—a parade, speeches, a shiny certificate. The old guard clapped and smiled, but I could see the calculation in their eyes. The title was a pretty ribbon on an empty box. No land, no money, just a name to keep me in line. Still, it gave me a place, a reason to stay, and sometimes that’s enough.

I was just an afterthought, given a title with no property or power, but at least it was official—good enough.

I learned to play the part—smiling, waving, letting the town ladies fuss over my dress at every event. People love a good story, and mine was just tragic enough to keep them interested, but not enough to make them care.

Julian’s mom, the respected Lady Carter, who was also the mayor’s aunt, had always been frail. After hearing the news, she fell seriously ill and didn’t make it through the winter.

The house grew quieter, the halls colder. I watched Julian move through his grief with a kind of grim determination, taking care of everything, never letting anyone see him falter. I tried to help, but some losses can’t be shared.

My days since then were comfortable enough. In the big old house, it was just the two of us, free as could be—sometimes drinking tea, tending the garden, or going to the county fair—living free.

We made our own little world—tea on the porch, tending roses, trading stories by the fire. Sometimes we’d sneak out to the county fair, eat too much cotton candy, and ride the Ferris wheel until we were dizzy. For a while, I thought we could stay like that forever, just the two of us against the world.

I thought it’d always be that way.

Life has a way of shifting under your feet just when you start to feel steady. I let myself believe in the comfort, in the routine, in the easy laughter that filled the house. But nothing stays the same for long—not in Maple Heights.

Next →

You may also like

He Was Meant for Her—But Chose Me
He Was Meant for Her—But Chose Me
5.0
He was supposed to fall for someone else. I was supposed to be the villain—until fate, a stubborn transmigrator, and a broken story system rewrote our lines. When I deliver a love letter for the third time to Carter Hayes, the boy I grew up with (and maybe secretly loved), I spark a confession that upends everything: Carter likes me, not the 'main girl.' But our world isn’t real—it's a story fighting to snap back into place, and every choice risks erasing us for good. As mysterious tasks, forbidden kisses, and heart-stopping resets threaten to tear us apart, I have to ask: Can love survive when the universe demands we play our roles? Or will the villain finally get her happily ever after—no matter what the script says?
I Became the Villainess—And Broke the Script
I Became the Villainess—And Broke the Script
4.9
Waking up as the notorious villainess in a brutal historical romance novel was never part of my five-year plan. My job? Torment the wild heroine Nora and win over the cold-hearted male lead, Carter. With a mind-reading perk and my office-honed instincts, I thought I could outplay everyone—but Nora’s stubborn warmth and Carter’s hidden cruelty flip the script. As secrets unravel at glittering galas and county fairs, I realize the stakes are more than reputation or romance: it’s about rewriting fate itself. When my sabotage puts everyone in danger, loyalty and love collide in a final, fiery showdown. Can a mean girl rewrite her story—or is she doomed to play the villain forever?
I’m the Villainess—Now I Write the Rules
I’m the Villainess—Now I Write the Rules
4.9
Being the villainess was never part of my plan—especially not in a small Southern town where everyone knows your secrets. When I wake up as Savannah Whitaker, the spoiled princess doomed to a tragic end, I decide to rewrite my fate: play matchmaker for the main couple, keep my head down, and maybe, just maybe, survive this story. But the plot has other ideas. The cold, dangerously handsome Mr. Carter isn't just my teacher—he’s the man I’m supposed to avoid, and he’s suddenly paying way too much attention. The gentle heroine, Elena, is as cunning as she is sweet, and every move I make only entangles me deeper in their world. Can I outsmart fate and claim my own happy ending, or will my attempts to change the story write my downfall? When the script flips, who gets to decide the ending?
I Was Never His Heroine
I Was Never His Heroine
4.9
Love was supposed to be simple—until I found out I was just the supporting character in his story. For three years, Carter Winslow kept me at arm’s length, refusing even the smallest touch. On the night I tried to break through his walls, my world shattered—mocking voices in my head, secrets I was never meant to know, and a cruel twist: I was never the heroine. Now, the real leading lady is stepping into the spotlight, and I’m left with nothing but heartbreak, humiliation, and a new resolve. If I’m destined to lose everything, why not flip the script? Will I fade out quietly, or will I set the whole story on fire before my exit? Who really controls the ending—me, or the narrative that wants me gone?
I Was the Villain—Until I Woke Up
I Was the Villain—Until I Woke Up
4.9
I was supposed to be the villain—until I woke up in someone else’s story. Quinn Mason’s life is a borrowed dream: fake friends, borrowed luxury, and a script where she’s destined to fall. But when she discovers her rival Maddy is rigging the game with mind control and a supernatural support rating, Quinn realizes the only way to survive is to flip the script—before Maddy turns the world against her. With every move watched, every rumor weaponized, and every friend a potential traitor, Quinn’s only hope is to expose the truth without losing herself. But when the lines between reality and fiction blur, who decides who’s the real villain? In a world where popularity is power and the rules are always changing, can Quinn become the hero—or is she just another pawn in someone else’s Everworld?
Kept by the Villain, Cast Aside by Fate
Kept by the Villain, Cast Aside by Fate
4.8
I’m the disposable rich girl—destined to be a side character, never the heroine. But when I pay the campus outcast to fake-date me, I discover he’s the secret villain the system wants me to fear…and the only one who ever truly sees me. As my family crumbles and the main couple’s love story devours my future, I must choose: betray my role, or risk everything for the boy I was supposed to ruin.
The Main Guy Chose the Wrong Girl
The Main Guy Chose the Wrong Girl
4.7
Rachel always played the part of the cold, perfect student—never the main character, always the villain in someone else’s story. But when the new transfer heartthrob declares he came for her, the entire school—and her so-called childhood friend—turn on her, hungry for drama. Now she’s caught in a viral love triangle, hated by the heroine, hunted by jealous rivals, and forced to choose: play the villain, or finally take the lead.
Rejected by My Alpha Wife, Reborn as the Villain
Rejected by My Alpha Wife, Reborn as the Villain
4.8
I married the ice-cold Alpha of Savannah to save her family, only to discover I was just a disposable villain in her twisted love story. After years of humiliation and heartbreak, I learn the shocking truth: my fate is to be betrayed and destroyed while she chases her true Omega. But this time, I refuse to play the fool—instead, I’ll rewrite the ending and make her regret ever casting me aside.
I Was the Villain, Now I’m Trending
I Was the Villain, Now I’m Trending
4.9
Falling for America’s sweetheart was never part of the script—but neither was waking up as the villain girl on a live gaming reality show. Now, every move I make is under the world’s microscope, every glance with Savannah (the girl I’m supposed to hate) becomes a viral ship, and my biggest rival is her gorgeous, mysterious brother. As alliances shift and the internet explodes with rumors, I have to decide: chase the win, protect my new friends, or risk it all for a love that’s as unexpected as my sudden fame. But with a possessive “lone wolf” prince and a meddling future mother-in-law in the mix, will my real happy ending survive the spotlight—or will I lose everything the moment the cameras stop rolling?
I Refuse to Be the Villainess
I Refuse to Be the Villainess
4.9
Fate always cast me as the villain, but what if I could rewrite the ending? The night my mother vanished, she warned me: when the beloved heroine enters our home, my world will collapse—and I’ll be the one blamed for every heartbreak and scandal that follows. Now, with Savannah dazzling my father and brother, I’m forced from my room, my reputation ruined, and my heart shattered by those I once trusted. But when a historic opportunity for women emerges in our town, I see a glimmer of freedom beyond the story’s script. If I refuse to play the villain, can I escape the fate written for me—or will jealousy and betrayal destroy my last chance at happiness?
I Woke Up as the Villain’s Wife
I Woke Up as the Villain’s Wife
5.0
Waking up as the tragic villain’s muse in a gothic romance, I thought I could dodge heartbreak and survive as a footnote. But when a cruel system ties my fate to Marcus Hawthorne—the brooding, misunderstood heir—I’m forced to play a deadly game where every wound he takes, I suffer. To survive, I must rewrite my doomed story, outsmart the hero and heroine, and win the villain’s trust without losing my heart. With assassins, poison, and forbidden secrets lurking in every shadow, every move could be my last. But as the line between enemy and lover blurs, I face an impossible choice: betray the man who could save me, or risk everything for a love that was never meant to exist. If you could rewrite your ending, would you dare to trust the villain?
Villainess Rewrite: Marry the Enemy
Villainess Rewrite: Marry the Enemy
5.0
I always thought I was the heroine—until I watched the real one fall into the lake, and my memories snapped into place. Turns out, I’m Autumn Whitlock: the villainess doomed to destroy her own family, locked away by the man she loves, and forgotten by everyone. But this time, I’m rewriting my ending. When a staged tragedy nearly frames me, I risk everything to save my rival—only to be rescued myself by Sebastian Carter, the cold and powerful heir with secrets of his own. Now, as old alliances shift and the threat to my family grows, I must outwit the story’s script, bargain with the enemy, and confront a marriage proposal that could save—or ruin—us all. Can a villainess steal back her fate, or am I destined to lose everything I love, one calculated move at a time?