I Loved Her Twice—She Chose Me Last / Chapter 1: Avalanche, Wolves, and a Broken Vow
I Loved Her Twice—She Chose Me Last

I Loved Her Twice—She Chose Me Last

Author: Benjamin Turner


Chapter 1: Avalanche, Wolves, and a Broken Vow

Next →

To stay by Mariah’s side—yeah, I know how that sounds—I gave up my shot at heading back to Chicago and finishing college.

That decision felt heavy as a winter coat in August. One I put on out of loyalty and longing, even with my old man’s voice rattling around in my head, warning me not to waste scholarships. Still, I couldn’t picture leaving her. Not when every breath I took seemed tangled up with hers.

She went alone, up into the Rockies to train with the old pack—her family, the shifters she’d grown up with—and that’s when she got caught in an avalanche.

Folks in town said the mountains were unforgiving. And when word got out that she was missing, you could feel the air freeze in the church basement. It was like the Rockies themselves had swallowed her whole.

Everyone thought she was gone for good. For a moment, I just stood there, numb, like I’d already lost her.

There were candlelight vigils, neighbors dropping off casseroles, and the kind of silence that only comes when hope’s running out. People started talking about her in the past tense. Like she was already a ghost walking the ridgelines.

But I drove all night—three states and then some—tore my hands raw digging. And I pulled her out from under the snow.

I can still feel the burn in my palms, the icy sting biting through my jacket. Adrenaline kept me moving when my legs wanted to quit. I remember shouting her name into the wind, refusing to believe she was gone. When I found her—half-frozen but alive—I just about dropped to my knees and thanked every saint I could name. My heart nearly burst with relief.

After that, she became my wife. I still remember the way my chest ached with hope, even as doubt crept in around the edges.

Our wedding wasn’t much—just a courthouse on Main Street, her hair still tangled from the mountains, my suit borrowed and a little too tight. But when she slipped that ring on my finger, I paused for a second, hardly believing it was real. I thought I’d finally outrun the shadow of losing her.

But when we were trapped together by a pack of wild wolves in the backcountry—

—moonlight glittering on the snow, our breaths coming out in sharp, scared clouds. The world shrunk down to just us and the howling outside.

She didn’t hesitate. She threw herself into the arms of Ethan—her true mate, the one she called her moon. I saw it all.

The way she moved, it was instinct. Like she’d been waiting her whole life for him to show up. I watched her choose, and it stung sharper than the cold.

"Ethan, if I get to spend my whole life with you—even die beside you someday—that'd be a blessing."

Her voice shook, but there was a faith in it I’d never seen before. She looked at him like he was the answer to every prayer she’d ever whispered.

The wolves’ heavy breathing drew closer. My own heart thudded in my chest, my skin prickling as the danger pressed in.

Snow crunched under their paws, their eyes catching the moonlight. You could feel them circling. It felt like the world was holding its breath, waiting for someone to make a move.

All I could do was smile, bitter and hollow.

It was the kind of smile you give when the punchline’s on you. I felt hollowed out. Like the mountains had scooped something out of my chest—and left me with nothing but wind and regret.

No resentment, no blame.

I wanted to hate them, I really did. But watching Mariah’s face, I just couldn’t. Some part of me understood—maybe always had—that you can’t force someone’s heart, no matter how many times you pull them out of the fire.

I asked Mariah:

"If I’d been the one to meet you first, would you have loved me?"

My voice was quiet, barely more than a whisper. I already knew the answer. But I needed to hear it all the same. Needed her honesty, even if it cut deep.

Mariah didn’t answer. Instead, she squeezed Ethan’s hand tighter, her knuckles white, her eyes shining with something I couldn’t reach.

That silence was louder than any shout. She held onto him like he was the only solid thing in a world that could crumble at any second.

Knowing what her silence meant, I calmly strapped the last bit of dynamite to my chest.

I remember the cold weight of it, my hands didn’t even shake. There was a strange calm that settled over me—like I was finally letting go of something I’d gripped too tight for too long.

Turning, I charged into the wolf pack. My boots bit into the snow, and for a heartbeat, everything felt sharper and more real than ever.

I could hear the wind rushing past my ears, the wolves scattering, the shock in Mariah’s voice. She called my name, but I didn’t look back.

If that's how it is, I wish you both a lifetime of peace and happiness.

It wasn’t a curse, just a simple blessing. I meant it. I really did. I closed my eyes—then everything went white.

Next →

You may also like

He Chose Her—So I Chose Me
He Chose Her—So I Chose Me
4.9
A car ride was all it took to shatter twenty years of sacrifice. When I, a devoted single mother, dared to sit beside my son, his girlfriend unleashed accusations that turned my world upside down—and my own child sided with her. I’d saved, planned, and dreamed for his future, only to be cast out and humiliated. As family lines blur and loyalty is tested, I’m forced to make a choice: cling to the son who betrayed me, or finally put myself first. Will my heartbreak become my freedom, or will the past pull me back in? When love turns to war, who gets the front seat in your life?
He Chose Her Over Me
He Chose Her Over Me
5.0
Natalie always believed her childhood love with Derek would last forever—until a wild outsider named Aubrey crashes into their lives, stealing his affection and her family's loyalty. Betrayed and replaced, Natalie must fight for her place in a small town where secrets, jealousy, and heartbreak simmer beneath the surface. She’s about to prove she’s nobody’s backup plan.
He Used Me, Then Chose Her
He Used Me, Then Chose Her
5.0
Natalie thought sharing a bed with her childhood best friend meant they were more than just 'buddies.' But when Ethan chooses another woman for a blind date, Natalie is forced to confront the truth: she was never the one. As humiliation and heartbreak threaten to swallow her, Natalie must decide if she’ll finally put herself first—or keep playing the part everyone expects.
I Loved Him—Then He Shattered Me
I Loved Him—Then He Shattered Me
4.9
He was always supposed to be the boy who protected me—but on the night I finally confessed, I learned just how fragile love can be. When Noah, my childhood fiancé, betrays me with the prom queen, my world shatters overnight. Forced to break our engagement and leave everything behind, I vow never to look back. But fate—and one stolen cat—pulls me into a final showdown I never wanted. Now, with heartbreak and hope warring inside me, I have to decide: can I ever trust him again, or is this goodbye forever? When the person you love most is the one who hurts you deepest, is a second chance ever worth the risk?
He Chose Her at the Altar
He Chose Her at the Altar
4.9
Natalie thought her marriage to small-town golden boy Derek would heal old wounds—but his heart is still haunted by another woman. When betrayal resurfaces at her own family’s doorstep, Natalie must decide: keep pretending for the sake of her daughter, or finally break free from a love that was never truly hers. Will she ever be more than his second choice, or is heartbreak her only inheritance?
I Was His Safe Choice—Now I’m Gone
I Was His Safe Choice—Now I’m Gone
4.9
He called me ‘marriage material’—but not worth loving. On the eve of our wedding, I discovered Mason’s spreadsheet: every woman ranked, every feeling reduced to a checklist, and my own column stamped ‘suitable for marriage.’ His heart still belonged to Jordan, the wild first love he’d never dare choose. My world collapsed, but instead of breaking, I ran—straight into the life I’d buried, the mother I’d lost, and the courage I thought I’d forgotten. As family secrets and old wounds ignite a public showdown, I must decide: will I keep living for someone else’s rules, or finally claim my own story? If you were chosen for convenience, can you ever become someone’s first choice—or is the bravest thing to walk away?
He Chose My Twin Over Me
He Chose My Twin Over Me
4.9
Emma’s world shatters when her fiancé confesses he truly loves her fragile twin, Sophia. Betrayed by her family and haunted by secrets, Emma is forced to choose between two lives—or risk losing everything. Will she finally break free, or be erased by the lies she’s been forced to live?
He Chose Her Over Me—Again
He Chose Her Over Me—Again
4.7
Emily always thought she’d be the Howell bride, until Chris shattered her trust—sacrificing her happiness for his mentor’s orphaned daughter. Humiliated, overlooked, and expected to give up everything for Lily, Emily finally refuses to play the gracious loser. When Chris announces his own engagement to Lily out of duty, Emily must decide: will she keep living in someone else’s shadow, or claim her own future—even if it means breaking every rule of Chicago high society?
I Loved Him First, But She Stayed
I Loved Him First, But She Stayed
4.9
Some heartbreaks go viral. When Ellie stumbles upon a brutal online confession from the 'other girl,' she realizes her boyfriend Noah—the boy who once crossed continents for her—might not be hers anymore. A promise ring tossed in the trash, a hometown gym filled with whispers, and a new girl glowing in his orbit: Ellie is forced to watch the life she built unravel in real time. But as she retraces every stolen glance and summer vow, she’s haunted by one question: Did she lose Noah to fate—or to the girl who showed up too late? In a world where love can vanish with a single post, can Ellie reclaim her ending, or will she always be the girl who came first—and lost anyway?
He Loved Me, But Never Said It
He Loved Me, But Never Said It
4.5
For seven years, Natalie loved Caleb—a brilliant, deaf scholarship boy who always kept her at arm’s length, no matter how hard she tried to bridge the silence. Humiliated at reunions, left out of weddings, and ignored by the man she thought was her forever, Natalie discovers the ring he never gave her and the secret he always hid: he was never sure he deserved her love. Now, standing on the edge of heartbreak, Natalie must decide if love can survive when the words are never spoken.
Rejected Twice by My Real Family
Rejected Twice by My Real Family
4.7
After my birth family finds me, the girl who stole my life walks into the sea—and everyone blames me. Beaten, shunned, and framed by my own blood, I’m cast out and forced to choose between begging for love or building my own future. But when fate rewinds and gives me a second chance, I pick the one person who truly wants me—my outcast Grandpa—and vow never to crawl for their affection again.
He Loved My Sacrifice, Not Me
He Loved My Sacrifice, Not Me
4.7
Natalie gave up everything—even her Olympic dreams—to protect Caleb, only to discover years later that he never loved her, only repaid a debt. Betrayed by the boy she trusted most and humiliated by his cruel friends, she finally reads the journal that shatters her last hope. Now, with his first love back in town, Natalie must choose: cling to the ghost of his gratitude, or walk away and reclaim her pride before she loses herself forever.