I Broke the Plot for His Love / Chapter 1: The Mean Girl’s Dilemma
I Broke the Plot for His Love

I Broke the Plot for His Love

Author: Anna Miller


Chapter 1: The Mean Girl’s Dilemma

Next →

Three years after I landed in this story, the male lead finally made his entrance.

I remember that day like it was yesterday—the sky a dull, pewter gray, wind rattling the bare branches outside our old house in Maple Heights. Dad brought him home straight from the frontlines—an orphan, just a skinny, shivering kid with nothing but the clothes on his back. He introduced him as Zachary Blake, and from that moment, Zach was one of us: sharing our last name, our roof, our lives. Maple Heights was the kind of neighborhood where folks noticed when someone new showed up—and Zach’s arrival got people talking.

In the original novel, as the notorious mean girl, I was always convinced the male lead was Dad’s secret child, and I made his life hell every chance I got.

I’d roll my eyes, toss my hair, and shoot him glares across the dinner table—you know, classic queen bee stuff. Looking back, I cringe at how far I took it, but that was the role I was supposed to play. The whole house seemed to hold its breath every time we crossed paths.

The system told me that as long as I stuck to the plot, I could go home.

It sounded simple enough: just follow the script, play the villain, and find my way home. But the more I lived it, the harder it became to keep my heart out of it.

But—

He was so soft, adorable, and heartbreakingly beautiful. I just couldn’t do it!

His voice was gentle, his eyes impossibly big and earnest. Every time he smiled, it was like a sunbeam cutting through the gloom of winter. I’d find myself wanting to shield him from everything, even my own scripted cruelty.

[Host, please complete the system task—make things difficult for Zachary Blake.]

The words blinked across my AR HUD in that annoyingly chipper font. I groaned, shoving my phone deeper into my pocket, but the system wouldn’t let up. Grabbing Daisy—my loyal golden retriever, always game for a walk—I headed for the guest wing where Zach stayed. Sometimes I still couldn’t believe I was stuck with this sci-fi system, all pop-ups and digital nagging, like I’d landed in a weird mashup of a fantasy novel and a video game.

As soon as I reached the doorway, I heard a shrill, nasty female voice: “Why isn’t Young Master Blake eating? Is the food not good enough for you? Didn’t expect a border-town stray to be so picky.”

That voice grated on my nerves, set my teeth on edge. I’d always known some of the help could be snobby, but hearing it out loud, aimed at Zach, made my blood boil. The way she said "border-town stray"—like he was less than nothing—just made me see red.

I knew there were always servants who bullied the weak and sucked up to the strong, but I didn’t think they’d be this bold.

It was the kind of thing you’d expect in a soap opera, not in my own house. Honestly, I half-expected a camera crew to jump out. My fists clenched, and all thoughts of the system faded. I could feel my face flush with anger, and Daisy let out a low, warning growl at my side.

I was instantly furious, forgot all about the system, and stormed in, giving the snotty maid at the door a hard shove.

She stumbled back, her eyes going wide. The room fell silent except for Daisy’s nails clicking on the hardwood floor. I didn’t even care if I got in trouble for manhandling the staff. Not this time.

She tumbled down, about to curse, but when she saw it was me, she shut up quick.

She bit her tongue, scrambling to her feet, and ducked her head, suddenly the picture of obedience. No one in the house dared cross me when I was angry—not even the adults.

With her out of the way, I saw the sad leftovers on the table.

A plate of cold mashed potatoes, a few limp green beans, and a slice of stale bread. My stomach twisted with guilt and anger. No kid deserved that, especially not in my house.

It was the dead of winter, but the room was freezing—no space heater, no nothing.

I could see my breath clouding in the air. The windows rattled in their frames, and even Daisy whined, pawing at my leg. The Brooks family might’ve been old money, but sometimes old houses meant old problems—drafts, creaks, and rooms that never quite got warm. You’d think money could fix a draft, but nope.

The boy’s clothes were thin. He looked up at me, nervous, and murmured, “Miss Mariah.”

His voice was so soft I almost missed it. God, he sounded so small. He sat hunched at the table, his hands curled in his lap, trying to make himself small. My heart broke all over again at the sight.

Looking at his big, watery eyes, my heart nearly broke. I hurriedly took off my puffy jacket and wrapped it around him. “I’m older than you. Since you’re Dad’s adopted son, you should call me ‘Sis.’”

He blinked, surprised, as if the idea had never occurred to him. The coat swallowed him up, but he looked a little less cold, a little less lost. Daisy licked his hand, tail wagging.

He blinked, surprised, then whispered, “Sis.”

His voice was barely there.

It was like he was testing out the word, tasting it on his tongue. The corners of his mouth twitched upward, just a little.

I patted his head, glared at the shivering maid, and snapped, “Doesn’t matter where he came from. Zach’s a member of the Brooks family now. What’s the rule for disrespecting your boss?”

My voice was sharp as ice. The maid shrank back, eyes darting to the floor. Daisy growled, as if she understood the stakes.

The housekeeper answered, “Twenty strikes and you’re out the door.”

Daisy, ever the loyal sidekick, barked once, then sat back on her haunches, looking pleased with herself. The maid’s face went white as chalk.

“Then go tell the house manager to deal with this trash.”

My words left no room for argument. I folded my arms and stared her down, daring her to protest.

“Yes, ma’am.”

She scurried off, nearly tripping over her own feet, desperate to escape my glare. I watched her go, then turned back to Zach.

As the maid begged for mercy, I handed my pocketknife to Zach in front of everyone and said, “Remember, you’re the boss, they’re the help. If anyone disrespects you again, don’t be afraid to stand up for yourself.”

I pressed the cool handle into his palm, making sure everyone in the room saw. "You don't have to take anything from anyone in this house."

Of course, playing the hero came back to bite me: I ended up with food poisoning and was stuck in bed for three days straight.

Turns out, I’d eaten something meant for Zach. Maybe the universe was punishing me for meddling, or maybe it was just bad luck. Either way, I spent three days feeling like death warmed over, with Daisy curled up at my feet and Zach sneaking in to check on me when he thought I was asleep.

Damn this stupid system.

I glared at the blinking HUD, wishing I could just reach through and throttle it. Even Daisy seemed to sigh in agreement.

[Detected host insulting the system. Please mind your language.]

A little pop-up window scolded me, complete with a cartoon frown. Seriously? Can you believe this thing?

Me: ...

Next →

You may also like

I Broke His Heart to Save Him
I Broke His Heart to Save Him
4.6
Natalie knows she’s just a side character destined to lose everything—the boy she loves, her family’s future, even her own dignity. To protect Caleb from a fate worse than heartbreak, she stages a brutal betrayal, forcing him to hate her before destiny tears them apart. But every lie she tells cuts deeper than the truth, and no one can ever know the real reason she let him go.
Scarred by Love
Scarred by Love
5.0
After sacrificing everything for the woman he adores, Derek is left broken when his girlfriend Natalie turns his devotion into humiliation. As betrayal and shame pile up, Derek must decide if loving her is worth losing himself—or if it's finally time to walk away. His heart is on the line, and the next move could shatter it for good.
Tricked by the Billionaire I Loved
Tricked by the Billionaire I Loved
4.8
For three years, I believed Jason was as broke and broken as I was—until a single stormy night shattered everything. Turns out, the man I sacrificed everything for was Chicago’s richest heir, slumming it for his own amusement while I begged, scraped, and planned to propose. Now, drowning in heartbreak and betrayal, I have to decide: walk away from the only love I’ve ever known, or make him pay for every lie he ever told.
She Loved Me—Then Broke Me Publicly
She Loved Me—Then Broke Me Publicly
5.0
He had nothing—until she made him her everything. Orphaned Ethan is swept into a world of marble floors and crystal chandeliers when heiress Madeline Carter chooses him for a love story that feels like a dream. But in a mansion where every shadow whispers doubt, passion turns to betrayal, and Ethan’s heart becomes collateral damage in games of the rich. When Madeline’s wandering gaze and public humiliations shatter what’s left of their vows, Ethan faces a choice: cling to a love that’s become his prison, or walk away with nothing but his pride. In a world where loyalty is currency and forgiveness is a luxury, can Ethan reclaim his worth—or will Madeline’s next act of cruelty finally break him for good?
I Let My Wife Die for My Mistress
I Let My Wife Die for My Mistress
4.8
The night my wife needed me most, I chose my first love instead—and my son will never forgive me. Now, haunted by guilt and shattered trust, I must rebuild a broken family with the woman who tore us apart. But when my son’s rage turns icy and unforgiving, can love ever wash away the blood on my hands?
Cursed to Love the General Who Hates Me
Cursed to Love the General Who Hates Me
4.8
I traded everything—my sight, my freedom, my pride—to keep the general alive, binding him to me with a love curse that turned his heart to ice the moment it broke. Now, after surviving his arrow and a thousand betrayals, I have just ten days left in a marriage haunted by his obsession with another woman. My blood may heal his beloved, but nothing will ever heal the hole he left in me—and when my time runs out, I’ll finally choose my own ending.
Ruined By My First Love
Ruined By My First Love
5.0
After being betrayed by the girl he once saved, Derek's world spirals into tragedy and poverty. Years later, when fate throws Natalie back into his life, old wounds bleed and new temptations threaten to destroy what little is left of his soul. He must choose between revenge, forgiveness, and a shot at reclaiming his stolen future.
I’m His Sister—But Fate Wants More
I’m His Sister—But Fate Wants More
4.9
Sometimes, the only way to rewrite a tragedy is to crash headfirst into it. Vanessa, a world-weary fixer, wakes up in a rain-soaked Midwest town with a single mission: give Mason Grant—the brooding, broken antihero—a shot at love and a happy ending. The catch? She's stuck playing his reluctant big sister, and he's the last person on earth who wants saving. As debts pile up, wounds both old and new threaten to break them, and every gesture of warmth risks crossing a dangerous line, Vanessa must outwit fate itself. But when the plot goes off the rails and real feelings get tangled with her mission, can she really change Mason’s story—or will she be written out for good? How do you teach someone to love when the world has only ever taught them pain?
Divorcing the Second Male Lead
Divorcing the Second Male Lead
4.8
I was just an extra in someone else’s love story—until my forced marriage to the second male lead became my only shot at survival. For three years, he cared for me through every illness, but when the heroine needed saving, he left me to die. Now, as I demand a divorce, he’ll do anything to keep me—even if it means crossing the line between love and obsession.
He Was Meant for Her—But Chose Me
He Was Meant for Her—But Chose Me
5.0
He was supposed to fall for someone else. I was supposed to be the villain—until fate, a stubborn transmigrator, and a broken story system rewrote our lines. When I deliver a love letter for the third time to Carter Hayes, the boy I grew up with (and maybe secretly loved), I spark a confession that upends everything: Carter likes me, not the 'main girl.' But our world isn’t real—it's a story fighting to snap back into place, and every choice risks erasing us for good. As mysterious tasks, forbidden kisses, and heart-stopping resets threaten to tear us apart, I have to ask: Can love survive when the universe demands we play our roles? Or will the villain finally get her happily ever after—no matter what the script says?
I Loved Him—Then He Shattered Me
I Loved Him—Then He Shattered Me
4.9
He was always supposed to be the boy who protected me—but on the night I finally confessed, I learned just how fragile love can be. When Noah, my childhood fiancé, betrays me with the prom queen, my world shatters overnight. Forced to break our engagement and leave everything behind, I vow never to look back. But fate—and one stolen cat—pulls me into a final showdown I never wanted. Now, with heartbreak and hope warring inside me, I have to decide: can I ever trust him again, or is this goodbye forever? When the person you love most is the one who hurts you deepest, is a second chance ever worth the risk?
Bought His Love, Lost His Heart
Bought His Love, Lost His Heart
4.7
I paid his rent, funded his dreams, and still, Sean gave his heart to someone else. Now, as a new, eager sugar baby tries to buy my affection with charm and ambition, I wonder if I’m just another transaction in this city of deals. When love is bought and loyalty is always for sale, who’s really using who?