The Heartthrob Called Me Gross / Chapter 3: Aftermath and Isolation
The Heartthrob Called Me Gross

The Heartthrob Called Me Gross

Author: Brett Donaldson


Chapter 3: Aftermath and Isolation

But today, it was as if he poured a bucket of ice water over me and woke me up.

My cheeks tingled with embarrassment. My ears rang. For the first time, I realized—maybe I really didn’t mean anything to him.

So, it turned out, I was never the exception.

I’d always hoped, stupidly, that maybe he’d see past everything and think I was special. I guess that was just a fantasy, something only a girl like me would believe.

Before the bell rang, Jason rubbed his brow and left the classroom.

He didn’t say anything else. Just slung his backpack over his shoulder, avoiding my eyes, and slipped out the door while the room buzzed behind him.

The class president dragged a chair over, sat beside me, and tried to comfort me.

I barely heard her footsteps over the pounding in my ears. She perched on the edge of her seat, an awkward smile plastered on her face.

"Don't be upset, Emily. Jason probably didn't mean what he said. And you can't really blame him, right? You know you... Isn't this just biting the hand that feeds you? He's always so nice to you. Even if you like him, you shouldn't have confessed... Now you've really disgusted him..."

Her words tumbled out, half-reassurance, half-accusation. I could feel my cheeks burning all over again.

To my horror, I realized I actually agreed with the class president. I could only nod and say softly, "I didn't know my place. When Jason comes back, I'll apologize to him."

The words came out so small, I wasn’t sure she heard me. But she nodded, satisfied, like a teacher patting a student on the head for the right answer.

The class president gave my shoulder an awkward squeeze, like she didn’t know what else to do. "Yes, just apologize and it'll be over. Actually, you're pretty cute—fair and round, like a marshmallow."

Her hand was soft, but the words felt sharp. I forced a little smile, just to get her to stop talking.

I automatically tuned out her last attempt at comfort and forced a faint smile.

Her voice faded into the background, replaced by the static of my own thoughts. I wanted to curl up under my desk and never come out.

You may also like

The Main Guy Chose the Wrong Girl
The Main Guy Chose the Wrong Girl
4.7
Rachel always played the part of the cold, perfect student—never the main character, always the villain in someone else’s story. But when the new transfer heartthrob declares he came for her, the entire school—and her so-called childhood friend—turn on her, hungry for drama. Now she’s caught in a viral love triangle, hated by the heroine, hunted by jealous rivals, and forced to choose: play the villain, or finally take the lead.
He Claimed Me—Back in High School
He Claimed Me—Back in High School
4.9
Waking up in her old high school body, Savannah thought she’d seen it all—until Carter Reed, the school’s untamable bad boy, starts declaring she’s his wife in front of the whole school. Suddenly, her quiet do-over is hijacked by rumors, jealous rivals, and Carter’s relentless (and ridiculous) pursuit. As Carter battles Diego, the heartthrob with Ivy League dreams, Savannah’s world spirals into chaos—detentions, band-aids, luxury brands, and family dinners where Carter fits in far too well. But beneath Carter’s bravado lies a heartbreak he can’t hide and a desperate need to rewrite his own future. Is this a second chance at love, or just another high school disaster waiting to happen? When Carter finally drops his guard, will Savannah run—or realize he’s the only one she’s ever wanted?
She Cheated With the Class Heartthrob
She Cheated With the Class Heartthrob
4.7
I thought we were planning our future, but behind my back, my girlfriend was sneaking around with her high school crush. I uncovered their affair one photo, one deleted message at a time—while she played the perfect fiancée, he played the doting fiancé to someone else. Now I’m left with the truth: I was just her cover story, and their betrayal cuts deeper than any lie.
Dumped by the Campus King
Dumped by the Campus King
4.9
Maddie’s secret online breakup shatters her carefully guarded world when she realizes her virtual boyfriend might be the college heartthrob she’s always avoided. As past choices unravel, she’s pulled into a dangerous, passionate collision with Caleb—a boy who won’t let go of heartbreak, or her. Now, her secret isn’t just out; it might destroy them both.
He Posted Her, Then Begged for Me
He Posted Her, Then Begged for Me
4.6
After two years chasing the campus heartthrob, Emily is humiliated when he goes Insta-official with another girl—then blames her when she finally walks away. Labeled a homewrecker and iced out by her classmates, Emily’s only escape is to leave the country, but now he’s desperate to stop her. Will she choose her own freedom, or let his last-minute regret pull her back into heartbreak?
My Future Husband Is My College Rival
My Future Husband Is My College Rival
4.8
Natalie thought college would be simple—until the campus heartthrob started shadowing her every move, desperate and jealous. He claims he’s her husband from the future, forced to win her love all over again, but she’s already tangled in a fake romance with her childhood friend. Now, with her heart—and her destiny—on the line, Natalie must choose: trust the boy who knows all her secrets, or risk losing her second chance at forever.
Mission: Boyfriend, But the App’s a Heartthrob
Mission: Boyfriend, But the App’s a Heartthrob
4.9
Waking up in a world where boy-love is the norm, Riley’s only way home is to 'capture a male lead'—but every attempt turns into disaster, and the app guiding him? It suddenly appears as a cute, painfully popular boy named Alex. From roommate chaos to kitchen disasters, Riley and Alex stumble through failed missions, wild escapes, and a series of hilarious near-misses. But as forced crushes fall flat and real feelings grow, Riley realizes the heart he’s been searching for was right beside him all along. Will Riley choose the scripted happy ending, or risk everything for the messy, real love that could finally set him free?
Dumped After Sleeping With the Genius
Dumped After Sleeping With the Genius
4.6
After two years of chasing campus heartthrob Caleb, Natalie finally wins his heart—and his bed—only to be humiliated at a party when he refuses her kiss and protects another girl. When the dare game turns savage, Natalie storms out with another guy, sending shockwaves through the gossip mill and breaking up with Caleb before he can break her. But as Caleb chases after her, desperate to explain, Natalie realizes this is her chance to walk away before she loses herself completely.
The Hollywood Queen’s Secret Husband
The Hollywood Queen’s Secret Husband
4.9
When Carter wakes up as the most hated dad on reality TV—secretly married to America’s Hollywood Queen—he’s thrust into a battle of bratty twins, online mobs, and a heartthrob rival. As the world watches every parenting fail, Carter must fight for his son’s trust and his own redemption, before the cameras catch his family falling apart for good.
I’m the Villain—Please Dump Me!
I’m the Villain—Please Dump Me!
5.0
Waking up as the villainous side-chick in a vampire soap opera is not on anyone’s bucket list—especially when your only hope of survival is to out-cling, outwit, and outlast both heartthrob vampires and a vengeful heroine. Savannah Carter is trapped in the body of a cautionary tale, faking love for the gentle second lead, dodging the real heroine’s wrath, and stumbling into one supernatural disaster after another. With deadly rumors, midnight rituals, and an ancient vampire alliance lurking behind every rose bush, Savannah must flip the script before she becomes the next blood bank—or worse, falls for the very monster who’s supposed to end her. Will she rewrite her fate, or is she doomed to play the villain until the credits roll?
Ghosted on Livestream: Justice for the Damned
Ghosted on Livestream: Justice for the Damned
4.9
Death doesn’t mean letting go—not when ghosts have Wi-Fi and an axe to grind. By night, I’m the afterlife’s snarkiest fortune-teller, streaming ghost justice to a chat full of skeptics and believers. My callers? A bullied boy haunted by a brow-obsessed spirit, grieving parents desperate for a missing son, and a heartthrob searching for his vanished wife. But every case uncovers a secret: the living can wound deeper than any curse, and sometimes love and hate are the same haunting. As my livestreams go viral, I’m forced to choose—let karma run wild, or break the cycle myself. In a world where grudges last longer than life, who really deserves to move on? When justice is just a livestream away, will you be the watcher—or the haunted?
Stolen by My Roommate
Stolen by My Roommate
4.6
When Marcus’s prank to humiliate his campus-heartthrob roommate backfires with a viral kiss, campus gossip ignites, reputations hang in the balance, and secret feelings refuse to stay buried. As rumors, jealousy, and a jumbotron Kiss Cam force them into the spotlight, Marcus must decide whether to keep hiding or claim the boy he never meant to love. If he chooses Caleb, there’s no take-backs—and the whole campus is watching.